Advertisements

Why The Last Airbender Fails

There was such potential for The Last Airbender film, based on the beloved Avatar: The Last Airbender American anime series, to be the start of a very lucrative and popular film franchise. The cartoon series is filled with humor, rich characters, intriguing mythos, action, adventure, romance, friendship, coming-of-age, etc. All sorts of amazing things in the source material which could have life breathed into it in a real-world setting.

Yet, from it’s very conception it was fumbled so horribly.

THE CAST

There has been a riot of protest against the casting choices made for this film and with good reason. You wouldn’t expect a cartoon cast that is racially diverse, with a plot that is set in areas of a fantasy world devoid of white people to be represented as anything other, right? Especially when their cultural heritage is so integral to the plot and the characters themselves.

Of course Hollywood would change that. They need to appeal to white people, the main contingency of their audience. While I don’t agree that is the case, Hollywood has explained their rational on many occasions. But instead of changing just one or two characters races  – they change them all. Aang is now Ong, a pouty lipped white boy. Katara, Sokka and their Grandmother are now the only white people in the entire Southern Water Tribe. All of the Northern water tribe is comprised of white people.

The Earth benders are Japanese, the Air Benders are mixed race, and the Fire Benders vary between East Indian and Middle Eastern, all featuring dark skin aside from Uncle Iro. So in this way Hollywood is allowed to perpetuate the myth that dark skin = bad and light skin = good. Again. As always. Even more shameful coming from M. Night Shyamalan, a director of color.

Gah – these turn of events are so horrible that people have been planning for years to boycott the movie. Unfortunately, I was caught up in the fervor of watching the television show with my nephews and agreeing to see the movie with them before I realized what had happened to the cast of one of my beloved shows. It’s either compromise my morals or break my nephews hearts at this point – so I sucked it up and chose to watch the movie.

At no point after reviewing the cast list did I believe it was possible for this movie not to suck. I had some hope. But a serious compromise of the core of the source material does not a good adaptation make.

Racebending is an outstanding website to catch yourself up on the whole phenomena.

THE NAME IS THE THING

And screwing up the name pronunciation of main characters is not EVER going to please a fan-base. So not only are the main characters completely the wrong races, but their names are also pronounced improperly. According to M. Night Shyamalan himself, he chose to use the root source of the words and had a linguist come in to explain all these details. OK – fine, but WHY bother doing this after you already horribly mangled the race of the characters? Why be sure to include something that will no doubt whip the fan-base into an even further frenzy?

Cause you really don’t care about the source material. You are already taking liberties and pissing on something beloved and who cares about getting it right? Grrrr. I don’t think I’ve been this insulted by an adaptation since The Last Stand or Spiderman: 3. Actually, this is probably worse. Not only did I visibly cringe and actually verbalize to the theatre every-time I heard the mis-pronunciation, but the pacing was off, the acting was subpar at best and the visual styles were all terrible as well.

THE FILM PARTS OF THE FILM

Were all awful. The really visual interesting pieces of the film (the bending) were few and far between, and for the most part the visual style was dominated by these strange really close-in and tight shots that didn’t allow you to absorb the action or the scene itself. Frowny face for that.

I don’t even remember anything compelling about the music, which was also one of the selling points of the cartoon series. Hearing the few opening strains of the beginning and end credit sequences was absolutely a comfort and delight when watching the show. There is nothing similar or engaging about the score for this film.

The acting was horrible. Jackson Rathbone has already proven in Eclipse he can’t act worth a damn, and it’s even further cemented here. Of course, he can’t help that all the joy of his character was written completely out, and he had nothing to do but act somber and bark orders. Ugh.

The chick who played Katara did a fairly passable job, but had zero chemistry with Aang. There was absolutely no hint of their romantic entanglement, and it’s fair to see why. Aang had no sparkle. No attraction as a character. Even with all the other pieces barely hanging together, the film could have been salvaged by the white actors BEING those beloved characters. But no.

TOO MUCH EXPOSITION

I am sick to death of boring-ass voice-overs in Hollywood movies doing the job of what a few minutes of snappy montaging at the beginning could take care of. And these voices randomly appearing – explaining exposition chunks that have ALREADY been covered within the movie? That’s just exceedingly bad film-making on so many levels. So many levels!!

Aang says: Hey guys, I'm sorry the movie was bad. But watch the original cartoon series, it's much better. You'll fall in love with me, I promise!

FINAL THOUGHTS

This film does not deserve as much attention paid to it as it’s getting. My only hope is that it’s release was able to convert fans (like myself) prior to viewing who will loathe the film itself but be that much more endeared to the source material. I for one, to make up for having viewed that piece of shit last night, will be sure to purchase the cartoon series.

Please – do yourself a giant favor – and watch the cartoon series. It’s worth so much more of your time and money and patience and love. This film is an insult to film and the love that went into its source material.

It makes me incredibly sad that it could turn off potential fans of the series because of its tragic ineptitude. Heed the warnings of those who have gone before and skip this monumental crap fest.

Watch at least the first two episodes of the cartoon instead. The entire series right now is streaming on Netflix Instant Watch. I guarantee you will fall in love or at least gain a better appreciation for the frustration of the fan-base.

As for M. Night Shyamalan, I would think no less than a public apology is going to secure him another chance at directing ever again.

BECHDEL TEST: PASSES the Bechdel Test for Women, PASSES the Bechdel Test for Men, and PASSES the Bechdel Test for Race.

Advertisements

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

About tinyheroes

Mindy Crouchley is a 33 year old woman with a degree in English and Technical Writing from Portland State University. She has accumulated three+ years experience in the Marketing and Communications field - with an emphasis on creating digital media content. She has been reading comic books since she was 10 years old. She currently lives in outer southeast Portland with her spouse Dan Robertson, her baby girl, and their dog - Jabba the pug. She spends her free time devouring books, crafting cosplay, video gaming, attending comic cons, writing stories/screenplays, attending book to film adaptation club meetings, volunteering, and watching copious amounts of TV and movies.

6 responses to “Why The Last Airbender Fails”

  1. Amanda says :

    Curiously, I decided to finally give this “kid’s show” a chance about six months ago. I was 21 at the time and the show began airing when I was 15 – a bit beyond it’s target audience. I kept reading posts on Tumblr about the show and thought, “Hey, maybe I should watch an episode or two, see what all the huff is about.” The next three days of my life were spent in front of my laptop, occasionally getting up for a bathroom break and that interruption I called a job, absorbing every episode from pilot to finale. When the end credits or the last episode started rolling, I felt like I’d just lost a dear friend. So, a month later I started the series again. And again, for the third time in less than a year, I’m almost nearing the end of the show. Why? Maybe at 22 years of age I haven’t quite grown up. Something about this cartoon has captured all of me, and I regret not being able to watch as an 11-year-old girl.

    When I decided to sit and watch M. Night Shyalamanalongname’s excuse for an adaptation, I got about six minutes in and turned it off in disgust.

    For the love of film and Avatar, do not. Watch. The film.

    • tinyheroes says :

      I agree with everything you say! We rewatched the entire series recently after the end of the first seasons of The Legend of Korra. LOK is alright, but Avatar: The Last Airbender is by far the superior product. So much humor, emotion and depth in the characters!

      It would be awesome if there were some easy way to force all my friends and family into watching a cartoon series. Alas, people will continue to give me the side-eye for enjoying it so much!

  2. Till says :

    Do you remember of Aang and his friends in the third book watching a theatre piece about themselves? I felt like them, disgusted, fooled… like, I was watching it and kept facepalming myself like Sokka in the episode of book 2, where they’re trapped in the labyrinth with those nomads. GOD DAMN that was an ugly piece of shit. Thank god that I didn’t spend money on watching this at cinema.

  3. Lisa says :

    I loved this sooo much! I want to cry right now this was absolutely beautiful. Everything you said was everything I was feeling about the movie!!!!!! I am a huge fan of the Avatar series and when I heard about the movie I was pretty excited to see it! But when I saw the commercial and the cast….I didn’t want to see the movie and didn’t bother to watch it. I just recently saw the movie and to my demise the movie was everything I knew it was going to be. AWFUL. I was very disappointed in every bit of the movie, from the bad acting to the disgraceful cast and the pronunciation of the character names. This movie was a huge disappointment and I’m hoping there is no triology or whatever to it.

Trackbacks / Pingbacks

  1. World Wide News Flash - July 4, 2010
  2. Spreading the Link Love 8/20/2010 « Tiny Heroes - August 20, 2010

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: